POLICY ORACLE
Devolution Series · Part 4

Devolution Series · Part 4 · Accountability: Siaya County

Siaya Finished Last of 47 on Revenue. The Blame Lies Mostly in Its Own Budget.

The county collected 13 per cent of its ordinary revenue target and left KSh 2.88 billion of its budget without a source of funds. Policy Oracle traces the gap to its authors: more than four-fifths to revenue targets the County Executive wrote and the County Assembly approved, the rest to national grants that never arrived. The cost fell on development projects, suppliers and village dispensaries.

Ordinary own-source revenue collected against target, FY 2025/26
13.36%
KSh 290.45 million against KSh 2.17 billion. Rank 47 of 47; national rate 59.55%.
Approved budget with no source of funds
KSh 2.88bn
21.5% of the KSh 13.38 billion supplementary budget
Share traced to targets set by the county
83%
Against a benchmark of 20% annual growth; see Figure 4
Share traced to grants the national level did not release
17%
KSh 501.27 million in additional allocations
Money received but not spent
KSh 3.00bn
KSh 1.76 billion still in the County Revenue Fund on 30 June 2026

01 · The verdictLast of 47, largely by its own hand

Siaya County set itself an ordinary own-source revenue target of KSh 2.17 billion for FY 2025/26. It collected KSh 290.45 million. At 13.36 per cent, that is the weakest performance of any county in Kenya: roughly half the rate of Bomet, the next-weakest county at 25.65 per cent, and less than a quarter of the national rate of 59.55 per cent.

A ranking of that kind invites a search for culprits. The obvious suspects are the revenue officers who failed to collect and the national government that failed to pay. The evidence in the Controller of Budget's report points elsewhere. Siaya's collections rose to the highest level on record. What failed was the number the county wrote into its budget and the decision to spend against it. Policy Oracle's apportionment of the resulting KSh 2.88 billion gap places more than four-fifths of it on the county's own budget-makers: the County Executive, which prepared the estimates, and the County Assembly, which approved them.

The target's size is what sets Siaya apart. Its ordinary target was the seventh largest in the country, larger than those of Kilifi, Murang'a and Kisumu, and two and a half times Kisumu's KSh 866 million. Its collections ranked 29th. The result is the fifth largest absolute shortfall in Kenya, KSh 1.88 billion, behind only Nairobi City, Kiambu, Mombasa and Narok.

Figure 1

Every county's ordinary revenue target against what it collected, FY 2025/26

Both axes are logarithmic. Counties on the diagonal collected their full target; the further a county sits above it, the larger its target relative to collections. Hover or tap any dot.

SiayaLake Region Economic Bloc countiesOther countiesCollection rate guides
Ordinary own-source revenue excludes Facility Improvement Financing (FIF). Collections on a cash basis (actual receipts). Source: Controller of Budget, County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report FY 2025/26, county revenue tables; Policy Oracle analysis.

Measured against the equitable share, Siaya raised KSh 3.75 in ordinary revenue for every KSh 100 it received from the national pool, against a national figure of KSh 10.44. That ratio places it 30th of 47, which is unremarkable for a rural county in the Lake Region: Homa Bay (KSh 4.56), Kakamega (KSh 3.84), Migori (KSh 3.39) and Vihiga (KSh 3.37) sit in the same band. Vihiga, a smaller county in the same region, finished first in the country because it set a target of KSh 170 million and beat it. Siaya's economy is not the outlier. Its budget is.

02 · The holeA KSh 2.88 billion budget built on money that did not exist

Siaya's supplementary budget for FY 2025/26 was KSh 13.38 billion. It expected to finance 24.31 per cent of that, KSh 3.25 billion, from its own revenue: KSh 2.17 billion in ordinary revenue and KSh 1.08 billion in Facility Improvement Financing (FIF) from its hospitals. It raised KSh 876.14 million. Total revenue for the year, including the KSh 961.81 million balance brought forward, reached KSh 10.50 billion, or 78.49 per cent of the budget.

That left KSh 2.88 billion of approved spending without a source of funds. Ordinary revenue accounts for KSh 1.88 billion of the gap, FIF for KSh 493.00 million and additional allocations that never arrived for KSh 501.27 million. The equitable share and the brought-forward balance arrived in full.

Figure 2

Where Siaya's budget expected its money to come from, and what arrived

Outlined bars show the amount budgeted; solid bars show receipts. The equitable share and the brought-forward balance arrived in full. Most of the hole is local.

BudgetedReceived
KSh million. Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.576; Policy Oracle analysis.

The ordinary revenue estimate had no foundation in the county's record. Ordinary own-source revenue stood at KSh 169.91 million in FY 2020/21 and reached KSh 290.45 million in FY 2025/26, a compound growth rate of 11.3 per cent a year. The FY 2025/26 target was 7.48 times the outturn. At its six-year growth rate, Siaya would reach KSh 2.17 billion in about 19 years. The FIF target, KSh 1.08 billion, assumed hospital revenue would more than double in a year from KSh 475.98 million.

Figure 3

Siaya own-source revenue, FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26, and the targets set for FY 2025/26

Switch to the target view to see the distance between six years of collections and the FY 2025/26 budget estimates.

Total OSRFIF (hospital revenue)Ordinary OSRFY 2025/26 target
KSh million. Source: Controller of Budget, Figure 3.221 and Table 3.576 (Siaya County Treasury data); Policy Oracle analysis.

The estimates also survived the one point in the year designed to correct them. The KSh 3.25 billion own-source revenue figure stood in the supplementary budget, which a county prepares once collections and spending are under way. By then the gap between the target and the run rate was visible to anyone reading the county's own revenue reports.

03 · The apportionmentWhere the blame should go

Every shilling of the KSh 2.88 billion gap has one of three origins. Part of it exists because the targets were set above anything the county could plausibly collect. Part exists because collections fell short of what a well-run revenue office could plausibly achieve. The rest exists because national grants were not released. The first belongs to the budget-makers, the second to the revenue administrators and the third to the national government and development partners.

Separating the first two requires a benchmark: what a realistic target would have been. Policy Oracle uses the previous year's outturn grown at a stated rate. At 20 per cent growth, a demanding but credible rate given that collections had grown 11.3 per cent a year since FY 2020/21, a realistic ordinary target would have been KSh 284.21 million and a realistic FIF target KSh 571.18 million. Siaya beat both. Its collectors outperformed the benchmark by KSh 20.76 million, which means the targets account for slightly more than the local share of the gap.

Figure 4

Who left Siaya's KSh 2.88 billion budget hole? Set the benchmark and see how the blame divides

A realistic target is last year's outturn grown at the rate you choose. Targets above that path are the budget-makers' share; collections below it are the revenue administrators' share; grants not released are the national share. The three always sum to the gap.

Realistic growth20%
KSh million. Benchmark: FY 2024/25 outturn (ordinary KSh 236.84 million; FIF KSh 475.98 million) grown at the selected rate. Siaya's actual growth in total own-source revenue was 22.91 per cent. Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.576 and Figure 3.221; Policy Oracle analysis.

The result holds under any reasonable assumption. Siaya's total own-source revenue grew 22.91 per cent in FY 2025/26; against any benchmark below that rate, its revenue administrators beat expectations and the entire local shortfall traces to the targets. Even on the extreme assumption that the county should have doubled its collections in a single year, the targets still account for 63.48 per cent of the gap, the national level for 17.42 per cent and the revenue administrators for 19.10 per cent.

Responsibility for the targets is not a matter of interpretation; the law assigns it. Section 129(2) of the Public Finance Management Act, 2012 requires the County Executive Committee member for finance to submit the budget estimates to the County Assembly. Section 131 requires the Assembly to consider and approve them, with or without amendments. Both offices put their names to a revenue estimate seven times the county's best year. The table of actors below sets out each one's share of the outcome.

Principal responsibility

County Executive and County Treasury

KSh 2.40bnof targets above a realistic path (20% benchmark)
  • Prepared the estimates under section 129(2) of the PFM Act and kept the KSh 3.25 billion OSR figure in the supplementary budget.
  • Let compensation overrun its budget by KSh 573.81 million and paid KSh 401.65 million through manual payrolls.
  • Ran a county that received KSh 3.00 billion more than it spent, ended the year with KSh 1.76 billion in the County Revenue Fund, and paid 38.87 per cent of its committed bills.
  • Did not refund FY 2024/25 balances to the County Revenue Fund, as the Controller found.
Shared responsibility

County Assembly

Approvedthe estimates under section 131 of the PFM Act
  • Approved a kiosk and stall rent target larger than all ordinary revenue the county has ever collected in a year.
  • Spent KSh 134.82 million on domestic travel, more than the entire County Executive.
  • Added KSh 77.06 million in new unpaid bills, the only new payables recorded in FY 2025/26.
  • Its Car Loan and Mortgage Fund, past its legal lifespan, disbursed a further KSh 1.00 million.
Contributing

National Treasury and development partners

KSh 501.27Mof approved allocations not released (17.42% of the gap)
  • Four allocations delivered nothing: KDSP Level I, health workers' salary arrears, DANIDA and housing committee allowances.
  • KDSP Level II delivered half; the Community Health Promoters allocation delivered 14.63 per cent.
  • The Controller directs the National Treasury to release approved allocations on schedule.
Contributing to the cash squeeze

Social Health Authority

KSh 287.48Min SHIF claims owed to Siaya facilities
  • Paid nothing against KSh 128.86 million in claims carried in from earlier years.
  • Left KSh 158.61 million of FY 2025/26 claims unpaid at year end.
  • The FIF target was unrealistic regardless, so SHA's arrears deepen the cash squeeze more than they explain the gap.
Minor

County revenue administration

-KSh 20.76Mcollections above the 20% benchmark
  • Delivered the county's best ordinary collection on record, up 22.64 per cent.
  • Still left eight targeted streams at zero and 22 below ten per cent of target.
  • Has automated 12 of 25 streams by its own count; the revenue table lists 41.

04 · The first chargeTargets written stream by stream on paper

The inflated total was not a single optimistic assumption. It was built line by line. The county revenue table lists 41 ordinary revenue streams. Thirty-seven carried a target. Only one, advertisement charges, met it, collecting KSh 25.46 million against KSh 11.55 million. Twenty-two returned less than ten per cent of target. Eight produced nothing at all: boda boda fees, grader hire, fire inspection, county hall hire, CILOR, site fees, private estate fees and school fees, which together carried targets of KSh 86.11 million. The Controller's findings list seven of them; county hall hire, targeted at KSh 161,700, is the eighth. Four streams that carried no target at all (seed sales, fertiliser sales, miscellaneous income and public health) produced KSh 17.75 million between them.

Figure 5

Siaya's ordinary revenue streams: target against collection, FY 2025/26

Sort the streams three ways. In the shilling views, the outlined bar is the target and the solid bar is what was collected. In the percentage view, red ticks mark streams that collected nothing.

Sort
Show

Show all 41 streams as a table
KSh million unless stated. Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.576 (Siaya County Treasury); Policy Oracle analysis.

Four streams carried the weight. Single business permits (KSh 636.0 million), kiosk and stall rent (KSh 387.6 million), market fees (KSh 345.7 million) and tractor hire (KSh 137.1 million) carried KSh 1.51 billion, or 69.3 per cent of the ordinary target. They yielded KSh 159.47 million. Kiosk and stall rent returned 2.56 per cent of its target; tractor hire returned 2.41 per cent.

These figures describe an economy that does not exist. A kiosk and stall rent target of KSh 387.6 million exceeds the county's entire ordinary collection in every year on record. A tractor hire target of KSh 137.1 million assumed a mechanisation service more than 40 times the size of the one that billed KSh 3.30 million. A collector cannot be blamed for failing to collect rent from stalls that, at those values, were never there to be rented. Plot rates, targeted at KSh 95.3 million, returned KSh 5.66 million: property rating barely functions in Siaya, and no target can substitute for a valuation roll.

Figure 6

What the target assumed against what actually paid

Share of the ordinary target and share of ordinary collections, by stream. Hover a segment to trace the same stream across both bars.

Plot rates and plot rent combined. Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.576; Policy Oracle analysis.

The revenue administration deserves a smaller and more specific charge. The county attributes the rise in collections to the move from manual to automated collection and to stronger enforcement. Its automation project absorbed KSh 28.63 million in FY 2025/26 and was reported 86.72 per cent complete, and ordinary revenue rose by KSh 53.61 million over the year. The investment is paying. But eight targeted streams produced nothing, and the county reports automating only 12 of 25 streams while its own revenue table lists 41. Those are failures of administration, worth fixing, and worth a few tens of millions of shillings. They are not the reason for a KSh 2.88 billion hole.

05 · The second chargeGrants never released and claims never paid

The national share of the blame is real and measurable. The county budgeted KSh 1.41 billion in additional allocations from the national government and development partners and received KSh 908.00 million, or 64.43 per cent. The KSh 501.27 million shortfall is 17.42 per cent of the gap. Four allocations produced nothing: Kenya Devolution Support Programme Level I (KSh 72.91 million), salary arrears for health workers (KSh 22.72 million), DANIDA (KSh 8.72 million) and allowances for housing committees (KSh 1.99 million). KDSP Level II delivered half its KSh 352.50 million. The Community Health Promoters allocation delivered KSh 9.33 million of KSh 63.81 million.

Figure 7

Additional allocations: budgeted against received, FY 2025/26

Sort by size of shortfall or by the share received.

Sort

BudgetedReceived
KSh million. Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.576; Policy Oracle analysis.

Hospitals carried the county's own revenue: FIF produced KSh 585.69 million, 66.85 per cent of all own-source revenue, a concentration the Controller flags as a risk. The FIF target was set entirely on Social Health Insurance Fund (SHIF) reimbursements, which delivered KSh 454.35 million against KSh 1.08 billion. Here the Social Health Authority shares the blame for the cash position, if not for the target. The revenue arrears table records KSh 158.61 million in SHIF claims earned in FY 2025/26 and unpaid at year end, and no payment at all against KSh 128.86 million carried in from earlier years. By 30 June 2026 Siaya's facilities were owed KSh 287.48 million, 86.10 per cent of all the county's revenue arrears.

Figure 8

The SHIF ledger: what Siaya's facilities were promised, earned, received and are still owed

Hover a segment for the amount.

TargetReceived in FY 2025/26Earned in FY 2025/26, unpaidUnpaid from earlier years
KSh million. Source: Controller of Budget, Tables 3.576 and 3.577; Policy Oracle analysis.

06 · The implicationsWhat the shortfall cost, and who paid for it

An unfunded budget does not fail evenly. When KSh 2.88 billion of appropriations has no money behind it, someone decides which commitments survive. In Siaya that decision was made through exchequer releases, not through the budget the Assembly passed: the Controller approved withdrawals of KSh 7.29 billion, 54.49 per cent of the approved budget. The practical effect of an inflated estimate is to move the real allocation of public money from the Assembly's appropriation to the Treasury's cash management.

Of the KSh 13.38 billion budget, KSh 7.50 billion was spent (including accrued expenditure), KSh 2.88 billion never existed, and a further KSh 3.00 billion arrived but was not spent. That last figure is a second charge against the County Executive. The revenue shortfall explains why the budget could not be executed in full. It does not explain why money that did arrive sat unused while suppliers waited.

Figure 9

What became of Siaya's KSh 13.38 billion budget

Hover a segment. Bars are drawn to the same scale.

SpentReceived or budgeted, not spentNever funded
KSh million. Spending includes accrued expenditure. Source: Controller of Budget, Tables 3.576, 3.578 and 3.585; Policy Oracle analysis.

The squeeze fell on development and operations, while the payroll was protected and grew. Employee compensation rose from KSh 3.34 billion in FY 2024/25 to KSh 4.44 billion, an increase of KSh 1.10 billion, or 32.81 per cent. Operations and maintenance fell 35.54 per cent to KSh 1.47 billion. Development spending fell 42.06 per cent to KSh 1.60 billion. The payroll grew by almost exactly the amount development lost.

Figure 10

The squeeze: payroll against development and operations, FY 2024/25 to FY 2025/26

Hover a line for the change.

KSh billion. FY 2025/26 figures include accrued expenditure. Source: Controller of Budget, Siaya County sections 3.38.7 to 3.38.9 and 3.38.15, Table 3.578; Policy Oracle analysis.

The payroll overran its own budget. Approved compensation of KSh 3.86 billion became actual compensation of KSh 4.44 billion, an overrun of KSh 573.81 million (114.86 per cent). The Executive's compensation absorption reached 115.87 per cent, with KSh 247.16 million accrued and unpaid at year end. The Controller puts the wage bill at 37.93 per cent of total revenue, above the 35 per cent ceiling in Regulation 25(1)(b) of the Public Finance Management (County Governments) Regulations, 2015. On Policy Oracle's calculation the ratio is higher: 42.25 per cent of the KSh 10.50 billion available, and 46.50 per cent of revenue received during the year once the brought-forward balance is excluded. The Controller does not state the denominator behind its figure.

Figure 11

Wage bill as a share of revenue, FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26

The FY 2023/24 spike to 59.54 per cent unwound, but the ratio has not returned below the statutory ceiling in six years.

Total wage bill to total revenueExecutiveCounty Assembly35% ceiling
Per cent, as reported by the county. Source: Controller of Budget, Figure 3.224 (Siaya County Treasury).

A further KSh 401.65 million, nine per cent of personnel costs, went through manual payrolls outside the Human Resource Information System, covering 2,299 payees: 477 staff never onboarded (KSh 202.36 million), 1,811 casual workers (KSh 196.16 million) and top-up allowances for 11 security officers (KSh 3.12 million). The manual payroll alone is 1.38 times the county's entire ordinary own-source revenue. The Controller warns that manual payrolls are prone to abuse.

Residents paid in projects and primary care

Development execution collapsed unevenly across departments. Roads, Public Works, Energy and Transport held the largest development budget, KSh 1.67 billion, and spent KSh 524.16 million (31.45 per cent), leaving KSh 1.14 billion idle. Governance and Administration spent 6.19 per cent of its development budget; within it, the Office of the Governor sub-programme spent KSh 31.02 million of KSh 387.33 million (8.01 per cent). Agriculture absorbed 9.38 per cent, Water and Environment 16.82 per cent and Enterprise and Industrial Development 16.13 per cent. Across departments, KSh 4.43 billion of development budget went unspent.

Figure 12

Budget absorption by department, recurrent against development, FY 2025/26

Each row joins a department's recurrent absorption to its development absorption. Re-sort to see which departments left the most development money unspent.

Sort

Recurrent absorptionDevelopment absorption
Show the department table
Absorption is expenditure as a share of the revised budget. Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.585 (Siaya County Treasury); Policy Oracle analysis.

Inside the health system, spending followed the money upward. The county's 175 facilities spent KSh 665.54 million, 61.70 per cent of their budget. The 16 Level 4 hospitals accounted for KSh 550.55 million, 82.7 per cent of the total, an average of KSh 34.4 million each. The 104 Level 2 dispensaries, the first point of care for most rural households, spent KSh 40.38 million between them: about KSh 388,000 per dispensary for the year, 30.34 per cent of their budget.

Figure 13

Health facility budgets and spending by level of care, FY 2025/26

Switch between total spending, spending per facility and absorption.

Approved budgetActual expenditure
Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.583 (Siaya County Treasury); Policy Oracle analysis.

Discretionary spending did not share the austerity. The largest operations and maintenance category was domestic travel and subsistence, at KSh 257.28 million, of which the County Assembly spent KSh 134.82 million and the Executive KSh 122.46 million. Travel alone equals 88.58 per cent of everything the county collected in ordinary revenue. Travel and hospitality together cost KSh 467.38 million. The county's 104 dispensaries spent less than a sixth of the travel bill.

Figure 14

Operations and maintenance spending by category, FY 2025/26

Add a reference line to compare the spending categories with what the county raised or spent elsewhere.

Compare with

KSh million. Source: Controller of Budget, Figure 3.225, Tables 3.576 and 3.583; Policy Oracle analysis.

Two features of the health accounts need explanation from the county. Facilities report spending of KSh 665.54 million, more than the KSh 585.69 million FIF collected, which implies the use of balances or other funding the report does not identify. And the Facility Improvement Fund recurrent sub-programme shows absorption of just 21.94 per cent (KSh 108.55 million of KSh 494.70 million). The two records cannot both describe the same money.

The projects that did move were mostly roads. Three market ring roads upgraded to bitumen (Usenge in West Yimbo, Sega in North Ugenya and Ndori in East Asembo) absorbed KSh 142.35 million between them and were reported complete. The county reported one stalled project: the Nyamonye Juakali sheds in Yimbo East, with an estimated value of KSh 1.88 million, on which KSh 3.72 million had already been paid, nearly twice the project's stated value. The Controller reports it as under investigation.

Suppliers paid in waiting

Siaya opened the year owing suppliers and contractors KSh 1.96 billion. Its payment plan committed it to clear the entire amount during FY 2025/26. It paid KSh 763.00 million, or 38.87 per cent. The Assembly added KSh 77.06 million in new bills. Outstanding payables closed the year at KSh 1.28 billion, while the county held KSh 1.76 billion in its County Revenue Fund account, 1.38 times its outstanding bills. For the businesses owed that money, many of them local, the county's revenue target is not an abstraction. It is the reason their invoices were approved and the reason they were not paid.

Figure 15

How Siaya's pending bills moved in FY 2025/26, against the cash it held

Hover a bar for detail. The dashed line marks the County Revenue Fund balance on 30 June 2026.

KSh million. Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.588 and section 3.38.5; Policy Oracle analysis.

The ageing tables raise a question of their own. They place KSh 1.04 billion of the Executive's KSh 1.17 billion in bills, 88.67 per cent, in the "under one year" category. Yet the payables table records no new bills incurred by the Executive in FY 2025/26. Both statements cannot be true. Salary arrears and statutory deductions account for KSh 173.01 million of the outstanding total, including KSh 45.28 million in unremitted pension liabilities.

Figure 16

Age of outstanding bills at 30 June 2026

Under one year1 to 2 years2 to 3 yearsOver 3 years
Share of each entity's outstanding trade payables. Source: Controller of Budget, Tables 3.589 and 3.590.

Credibility paid in the next budget

The longest-running cost is to the budget itself. A county that approves revenue it cannot collect carries the consequences forward: bills that roll into the next year, projects that restart at higher cost, and an Assembly whose appropriations no longer predict what will be spent. Unless the FY 2026/27 estimates break with the pattern, Siaya will open the year with KSh 1.28 billion in old bills to settle from a revenue base that has never exceeded KSh 876 million in own-source collections.

07 · The governance recordLapsed funds and 232 commercial bank accounts

Siaya allocated KSh 575.51 million, 4.30 per cent of its budget, to county-established funds. The Emergency Fund received an allocation of KSh 180 million and an exchequer release of KSh 20 million, and disbursed nothing. Two funds have outlived their legal life. Regulation 197(1)(i) of the PFM (County Governments) Regulations, 2015 caps a fund's lifespan at ten years unless the County Assembly extends it. The Bursary Fund, established in 2013, and the County Assembly Car Loan and Mortgage Fund, established in 2015, have both lapsed, after cumulative disbursements of KSh 732.10 million and KSh 454.71 million respectively. The Controller directs that both be wound up and their balances refunded to the County Revenue Fund.

Table 1

Siaya County-established funds, FY 2025/26

KSh million. Source: Controller of Budget, Table 3.581.

The county operated 254 bank accounts. Only 22 were at the Central Bank of Kenya, where Regulation 82(1)(b) of the same regulations requires county accounts to be held, with narrow exceptions for imprest and revenue collection. The other 232 were at commercial banks, 215 of them for health facilities, more than the 175 facilities in the county's own expenditure table. The county did not submit the authorisation letters that Regulation 82(5) requires it to file with the Controller.

Figure 17

Siaya's 254 bank accounts, one square each

Hover or tap a category to isolate it.

Source: Controller of Budget, section 3.38.19.

The county's three municipalities, Siaya, Bondo and Ugunja, were allocated KSh 495.65 million and spent KSh 179.85 million, 36.28 per cent. The County Assembly Fund had not been operationalised by 30 June 2026.

08 · The official recordWhat the Controller of Budget found

The Controller listed ten challenges in Siaya's budget implementation. Policy Oracle summarises them below, with one correction. The Controller's first finding states that own-source revenue of KSh 876 million represented "22.91 per cent" of the annual target. That figure is the year-on-year growth rate. Measured against the KSh 3.25 billion target, as the Controller's own revenue section states, the correct figure is 26.94 per cent.

09 · The remedyWhat each actor must do

Siaya's revenue problem is real but modest; its budgeting problem is severe. Accountability should follow the apportionment. Policy Oracle recommends eight measures, addressed to the offices responsible.

  1. County Treasury: reset the ordinary revenue target to evidence. Anchor the FY 2026/27 estimate on the FY 2025/26 outturn and a defensible growth path. On the 20 to 25 per cent growth that automation delivered this year, that implies a target in the range of KSh 350 million to KSh 365 million, not KSh 2.17 billion. Publish stream-by-stream assumptions with the budget.
  2. County Assembly: test the revenue estimates before approving them. The Budget and Appropriations Committee should reject any stream target that exceeds the previous year's outturn by more than a stated margin unless the Executive shows the new base (traders registered, stalls built, properties valued) that supports it, and should use the supplementary budget to correct targets that the run rate has already disproved.
  3. County Executive: use cash to pay verified bills. With KSh 1.76 billion in the County Revenue Fund and KSh 1.28 billion in bills, the county can retire a large share of its verified, older payables now, beginning with the KSh 173.01 million in salary arrears and statutory deductions.
  4. County Executive and Public Service Board: stop the payroll drift. Onboard the 477 staff outside the HRIS, regularise casual engagement under section 74 of the County Governments Act, 2012, and bring compensation back within budget before any new hiring.
  5. Revenue administration: fix the streams that carry the target. Business permits, kiosk and stall rent and market fees should sit in one automated register with a verified count of traders and stalls. Tractor hire should be repriced on its real fleet and demand, or removed from the target. The National Rating Act, 2024, in force since December 2024, provides the legal route to a current valuation roll.
  6. National Treasury and partners: release what was approved. Disburse approved allocations on the published schedule, and where a grant depends on conditions the county must meet, state which conditions were missed so the Assembly can hold the Executive to them.
  7. Social Health Authority and County Health Services: settle and reconcile. SHA should clear the KSh 287.48 million owed to Siaya facilities. The county should reconcile facility spending with FIF collections and the FIF sub-programme, and consolidate its 215 facility bank accounts under the authorisation the regulations require.
  8. Both arms of the county: move money from travel to primary care, and close the lapsed funds. A 30 per cent cut in domestic travel would free KSh 77.18 million, enough to nearly triple what the 104 dispensaries spent in FY 2025/26. The Bursary Fund and the Car Loan and Mortgage Fund should be wound up as the Controller directs.
The lesson for other counties. Siaya is the extreme case of a pattern Parts 1 to 3 of this series documented across Kenya: county revenue targets set to close budget gaps rather than to forecast collections. A target that cannot be met does not discipline a budget. It hides a deficit inside it, and it moves the blame for that deficit from the people who wrote it to the people asked to collect it.

NotesMethod and data

  1. All figures come from the Siaya County chapter (section 3.38) of the Controller of Budget's County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report for FY 2025/26, published in August 2026, and from the national revenue tables in the same report used in Parts 1 to 3 of this series. National comparisons use ordinary own-source revenue on a cash basis, as in Part 2.
  2. Apportionment method (Figure 4). The funding gap of KSh 2,877.56 million equals the shortfall in ordinary OSR (KSh 1,883.29 million), FIF (KSh 493.00 million) and additional allocations (KSh 501.27 million). A benchmark target is the FY 2024/25 outturn (ordinary KSh 236.84 million; FIF KSh 475.98 million) grown at the selected rate. The target-setting component is the approved target minus the benchmark; the collection component is the benchmark minus actual receipts, negative where collections beat the benchmark; the national component is the additional allocations not released. The three sum to the gap at every rate. The benchmark is Policy Oracle's analytical device, not a statutory standard.
  3. Ordinary own-source revenue excludes Facility Improvement Financing. The stream-level collections in Table 3.576 sum to KSh 290,450,789, one shilling above the subtotal of KSh 290,450,788; the difference is rounding in the source.
  4. Total expenditure of KSh 7.50 billion is taken from Table 3.578 and includes accrued expenditure. The Controller's narrative gives KSh 7.18 billion, which matches cash payments only. "Received but not spent" is total revenue of KSh 10,500.43 million less expenditure of KSh 7,504.73 million.
  5. The Controller reports the wage bill at 37.93 per cent of total revenue without stating the denominator. Policy Oracle's ratios use total revenue of KSh 10.50 billion and in-year receipts of KSh 9.54 billion.
  6. The departmental table (Table 3.585) reports development spending of KSh 50.42 million for Agriculture, Food, Livestock and Fisheries, while the programme table (Table 3.586) reports KSh 420.52 million spent on the Crop Management sub-programme within the same department. Policy Oracle uses the departmental table for absorption.
  7. The Controller's text refers to Tables 3.554, 3.86 and 3.90 in the Siaya section; the relevant tables are 3.577, 3.581 and 3.585. The arrears narrative omits the unit for the SHIF and ordinary components (KSh 287.48 million and KSh 46.42 million).
  8. Some additional allocations, including KDSP Level II, are performance-based and depend on conditions the county must meet. The report does not say why individual allocations were withheld; Policy Oracle assigns the shortfall to the national level and partners, as the Controller's recommendation does, while noting that the county may share responsibility for conditional grants.
  9. Lake Region Economic Bloc membership used in Figure 1: Bomet, Bungoma, Busia, Homa Bay, Kakamega, Kericho, Kisii, Kisumu, Migori, Nandi, Nyamira, Siaya, Trans Nzoia and Vihiga.
Start the series from the beginning: Part 1The Efficiency Illusion