POLICY ORACLE
Devolution Series  |  Public Finance

Devolution Series, Part 3 · Facility Improvement Financing · FY 2025/26

The Hospital Dividend: How Health Money Is Rewriting County Revenue Reports

Facility Improvement Financing supplied 44 per cent of the cash Kenya’s counties collected in FY 2025/26 and beat its target, while ordinary revenue fell 40 per cent short. Seven of the ten counties that met their revenue targets did so only because of hospital money. Behind those figures sit KSh 8.86 billion in unpaid health claims and reporting gaps worth billions of shillings.

Map of Kenya highlighting in amber the counties that draw 75 per cent or more of their own-source revenue from Facility Improvement Financing, led by Garissa at 86.8 per cent, and Nakuru in red with KSh 4.27 billion in unpaid health claims.
Graphic: Policy Oracle. Data: Controller of Budget, CGBIRR FY 2025/26.

The Efficiency Illusion, the first article in this series, showed that Kenya’s counties collected 73.91 per cent of their own-source revenue (OSR) target in cash in FY 2025/26, and only 59.55 per cent of their target for ordinary revenue: the rates, permits, cess and fees that measure a county’s own tax effort. The gap between those two numbers is one revenue stream. This part examines it.

Facility Improvement Financing (FIF) is the money public hospitals, health centres and dispensaries earn from the services they provide. Under the Facilities Improvement Financing Act, 2023, facilities collect and keep that money at source instead of surrendering it to the County Revenue Fund, and Section 29 of the Act lets each county pass its own law to put the arrangement into operation. Most FIF now arrives as reimbursements from the Social Health Insurance Fund (SHIF), administered by the Social Health Authority. Smaller sums come from patients paying cash, other insurers and residual payments from the defunct National Hospital Insurance Fund (NHIF). The Controller of Budget counts all of it as county OSR, and each county sets a FIF target alongside its ordinary revenue target.

The Controller has seen the risk. Its report devotes a section to the “overreliance on Facility Improvement Financing as a revenue stream”, and its executive summary attributes the year’s improved revenue figures mainly to accrual-based reporting, the inclusion of revenue arrears and stronger FIF performance, including SHIF reimbursements. It recommends that counties broaden their ordinary revenue, ring-fence facility money for health purposes and disclose FIF separately. This analysis does that disclosure county by county, on cash received.

Share of counties’ OSR cash that came from FIF, FY 2025/26
FIF collected against its target
Ordinary OSR: 59.55% of its target
Counties where FIF is more than half of OSR
Of 46 counties with comparable FIF data
Counties above target only because of FIF
7 of 10
Each misses its ordinary OSR target
Health claims billed in 2025/26 and unpaid

Graph 1How much FIF lifts the scorecard

Each row below shows a county’s collection rate twice: on ordinary revenue alone, and on total OSR including FIF. The distance between the two dots is what health money adds to, or in a few cases takes from, the county’s score. Nationally, FIF adds 14.4 percentage points, lifting a 59.55 per cent ordinary performance to 73.91 per cent overall.

Ordinary OSR against total OSR as a share of target, by county, FY 2025/26
Cash received. Sorted by the points FIF adds. Hover or tap a row for detail.
Ordinary OSR onlyTotal OSR, including FIF
Source: Controller of Budget, CGBIRR FY 2025/26, county revenue tables (actual receipts) and Table 2.1 (targets). Policy Oracle calculations. Nyeri is excluded because the Controller omitted its FIF. * See notes.

For several counties, FIF is the difference between failure and success. Makueni collected 47.82 per cent of its ordinary target, but its total rises to 102.21 per cent once KSh 1.19 billion of FIF is counted, a lift of 54 points. Kirinyaga gains 46 points, Bomet 44 points (from 25.65 per cent to 69.55 per cent) and Garissa 42 points. Seven of the ten counties that met their overall targets, Garissa, Kirinyaga, Laikipia, Lamu, Makueni, Samburu and Wajir, missed their ordinary OSR targets. On the Controller’s scorecard they appear as revenue performers. On their own tax effort, they are not.

In a handful of counties FIF pulls the score down. Kisumu loses 45 points because its FIF target of KSh 2.67 billion included KSh 1.87 billion of SHIF receivables brought forward from earlier years, money it did not collect in the year. Baringo, where FIF reached only 53.82 per cent of target, loses 11 points; Turkana loses 8. Vihiga loses 6 points for a better reason: its ordinary revenue, at 119.18 per cent of target, outperformed its FIF.

Graph 2Where counties depend on hospital money

In 32 of the 46 counties with comparable data, FIF supplied more than half of all OSR cash. The map shades each county by that share.

FIF as a share of OSR received, by county, FY 2025/26
Cash received. Hover or tap a county for its figures.
Source: Controller of Budget, CGBIRR FY 2025/26; Policy Oracle calculations. Nyeri is hatched: the Controller omitted its FIF from the national tables. County boundaries: kenya-election-data (GitHub, mikelmaron), simplified.

Dependence is deepest in the agricultural west and the north-east. Garissa drew 86.8 per cent of its OSR cash from FIF, Elgeyo-Marakwet 81.1 per cent and Nyamira 78.9 per cent, followed by Wajir, West Pokot, Homa Bay and Bomet, all above 75 per cent. Busia and Siaya, Homa Bay, Kisii, Nyamira and Bomet form a belt of high dependence through western Kenya and Nyanza, each above 65 per cent.

The least dependent counties have another large revenue base. Narok (4.3 per cent), where park fees brought in KSh 3.96 billion, and Samburu (25.8 per cent) live on tourism; Nairobi City (18.5 per cent) on land rates and other urban charges. Tana River’s share of 2.5 per cent reflects a FIF return of only KSh 3.01 million, which says more about its reporting than its hospitals. The Controller warns that heavy reliance on a single stream exposes counties to concentration risk. The risk is sharper than that: a county whose OSR is three-quarters hospital money depends on the payment schedule of a national insurance fund it does not control.

Graph 3Targets that miss in both directions

FIF performance is measured against targets each county sets in its own budget. Six counties collected more than 150 per cent of their FIF targets; eight collected less than 75 per cent.

FIF received as a share of FIF target, FY 2025/26
Cash received. Select a view. Hover or tap a bar for detail.
Source: Controller of Budget, CGBIRR FY 2025/26. FIF excludes Appropriations-in-Aid. Samburu (no FIF target) and Nyeri (FIF omitted) are not shown. * See notes.

Six counties collected more than one and a half times their FIF targets. Nairobi City received KSh 2.87 billion against a target of KSh 1.24 billion, or 232.59 per cent. Kirinyaga reached 214.26 per cent, Makueni 199.00 per cent, Bomet 161.46 per cent, Machakos 160.83 per cent and Narok 156.76 per cent. Samburu set no FIF target and received KSh 117.11 million; Wajir received KSh 165.92 million from the defunct NHIF with no target attached. These counties did not suddenly become efficient. Their budgets did not anticipate how much the new insurance system would pay.

Eight counties fell below three-quarters of target. Kisumu (26.01 per cent) carried old receivables in its target. Kajiado (52.59 per cent) collected KSh 298.94 million in cash but was owed KSh 787.68 million in health claims billed during the year; had those been paid, it would have reached 191 per cent. Baringo, Siaya, Isiolo, Tana River, Mandera and Nyamira complete the group. When targets miss by this much in both directions, FIF performance measures the quality of the forecast and the timing of insurance payments, not the effort of county revenue officers.

Graph 4What FIF is made of

Counties reported KSh 34.69 billion of FIF received in cash. The bar below splits it by what the county tables say the money is.

Composition of FIF received, FY 2025/26
National total, then each county. Hover or tap a segment for amounts.
Source: Controller of Budget, CGBIRR FY 2025/26, county revenue tables (actual receipts). Categories assigned by Policy Oracle from each county’s stream labels. “Not itemised”: the county reported FIF as a single line with no breakdown. Nyeri is omitted from the national tables.
Show the data as a table

A little over half of FIF is labelled as insurance money. Thirty-four counties identify KSh 19.45 billion, 56 per cent of the total, as SHIF or SHA reimbursements. A further KSh 2.07 billion (6 per cent) is cash paid by patients and other facility income, led by Kiambu’s KSh 689.94 million in hospital collections, Meru’s KSh 517.19 million from “other FIF sources” and Makueni’s KSh 288.73 million in medical service fees. Defunct NHIF payments account for KSh 166 million, almost all of it in Wajir.

The rest, KSh 13.01 billion or 37.5 per cent, is a black box. Twelve counties report FIF as a single undifferentiated line. Five of them, Nairobi City (KSh 2.87 billion), Nakuru (KSh 2.72 billion), Kisii (KSh 1.74 billion), Machakos (KSh 1.60 billion) and Bungoma (KSh 1.17 billion), hold 78 per cent of the unexplained sum. Nyeri does not appear at all: the Controller omitted its FIF from the national tables for inconsistent reporting, although the county’s own chapter names FIF of KSh 1.37 billion as its largest revenue stream. Without a breakdown, no one outside these counties can tell how much of their hospital revenue comes from insurance and how much from the pockets of patients, a distinction that matters both for forecasting and for the cost of care.

Graph 5The unpaid claims

Hospitals bill the insurance fund after they treat patients, and payment follows later. During FY 2025/26 counties billed KSh 8.86 billion in FIF that remained unpaid on 30 June 2026, equal to a quarter of the FIF cash they received. Across all years, unpaid FIF receivables rose from KSh 7.78 billion to KSh 11.37 billion, an increase of 46 per cent.

Change in unpaid FIF receivables, 1 July 2025 to 30 June 2026
Red: receivables grew. Blue: receivables fell. Hover or tap a bar for opening and closing balances.
Receivables grewReceivables fell
Source: Controller of Budget, CGBIRR FY 2025/26, Table 2.2 and county revenue arrears tables. Tharaka-Nithi’s closing FIF balance is taken from its county table because Table 2.2 places it in the wrong column. Counties with no FIF receivables at either date are not shown.

Nakuru’s unpaid health receivables almost quintupled. They rose from KSh 909.27 million to KSh 4.27 billion, an increase of KSh 3.36 billion that accounts for nearly all of the national rise. Mombasa billed KSh 2.24 billion in SHIF claims during the year that remained unpaid, Nakuru KSh 1.55 billion, Nyeri KSh 901 million, Kiambu KSh 806 million and Kajiado KSh 788 million. Some counties made progress: Kakamega cut its FIF receivables by KSh 733 million, Mombasa by KSh 359 million after collecting old claims and waiving KSh 184 million, and Bungoma cleared its KSh 359 million balance entirely.

The Controller’s own totals understate the problem. Table 2.2 prints opening FIF receivables of KSh 7.42 billion and closing receivables of KSh 11.20 billion. Its opening total leaves out Bungoma’s KSh 358.55 million, and its closing total misses Tharaka-Nithi’s KSh 167.23 million, which the table records in the ordinary revenue column. Summed county by county, the figures are KSh 7.78 billion and KSh 11.37 billion. For a county hospital, an unpaid claim is a drug order not placed and a supplier not paid.

AccrualBooked, not banked, in health

The Controller reports FIF of KSh 39.75 billion for the year, KSh 5.06 billion more than counties received in cash. Of the difference, KSh 4.98 billion is health receivables that nine counties booked as revenue, led by Mombasa (KSh 3.09 billion, including KSh 322.79 million of claims on the defunct NHIF), Nakuru (KSh 847.72 million), Kitui (KSh 303.24 million) and Garissa (KSh 254.37 million). The remaining KSh 76.18 million is an error: Table 2.1 counts Elgeyo-Marakwet’s ordinary revenue a second time inside its FIF figure. Kisumu’s county table goes furthest, recording KSh 1.87 billion of SHIF receivables brought forward from earlier years as part of the year’s FIF revenue, against a target that included them.

The Controller puts FIF at 40.75 per cent of reported OSR. On cash received, the share is higher, at 44.09 per cent, because accrual entries inflate ordinary revenue even more than they inflate FIF: Mombasa alone booked KSh 11.82 billion of ordinary arrears.

On the groundWhat the Controller found in the facilities

The Controller’s monitoring of the Facilities Improvement Financing Act, reported in Chapter Five, found implementation uneven across counties. Some counties had not enacted the county legislation, regulations or policy frameworks that Section 29 of the Act anticipates. In several counties, the officers in charge of health facilities had not been briefed on Section 23, which requires accounting officers of facilities to prepare and submit annual financial statements within three months of the year end. The Controller recommends faster county legislation and structured training for facility in-charges on their reporting duties.

The money can work. The same chapter shows an endoscopy system and a laparoscopic surgical tower at the Garissa County Referral Hospital, both bought with FIF. The reporting gaps documented above, an omitted county, a double count, receivables booked as revenue and KSh 13 billion reported without a breakdown, are the national symptoms of the facility-level weaknesses the Controller describes.

Data explorerFIF in every county

All 47 counties as a heatmap. The red-to-blue columns measure cash received against target. The blue column shows how much of each county’s OSR came from FIF. Click any column heading to sort; figures in KSh million unless stated.

“No target”: the county set no FIF target. “Omitted”: the Controller left the county’s FIF out of the national tables. * See the data notes.

ImplicationsWhat this means for devolution policy

FIF is doing what the 2023 Act intended: putting money in the hands of health facilities. The problem is not the money but the way it is reported and judged. Folded into OSR, it makes counties look like stronger tax collectors than they are, and it hides the liquidity strain that unpaid claims impose on hospitals. Five reforms follow.

  1. Publish two scorecards. The Controller already recommends disclosing FIF separately. It should go further and report county revenue effort on ordinary OSR alone, with FIF assessed in a separate health-financing table. On ordinary revenue, seven of this year’s ten target-beaters fall short.
  2. Set FIF targets from claims data. Six counties collected more than one and a half times their FIF targets and eight less than three-quarters. Targets should be built from SHA claim volumes, approved tariffs and payment history at each facility, not carried forward from the previous budget.
  3. Standardise what counties report. Every county should split FIF into SHIF and SHA reimbursements, legacy NHIF, cash paid by patients and other insurers, at facility level. No county’s FIF should be omitted from the national tables, as Nyeri’s was, or reported as a single unexplained line, as KSh 13 billion was this year.
  4. Track and settle claims. Unpaid FIF receivables stand at KSh 11.37 billion. The Social Health Authority should publish a claims payment schedule by county, and counties should publish aged registers of unpaid claims. Receivables should never be booked as the year’s revenue.
  5. Keep FIF out of measures of fiscal effort. Any allocation, award or ranking that rewards county revenue effort should use ordinary OSR. FIF should be judged on what it buys: claims paid on time, drugs on shelves and equipment in theatres.

The national health financing reform is filling county hospital accounts faster than county treasuries are building their own tax base. That is good news for patients and a warning for devolution. A county that cannot raise its own revenue remains, in the end, a dependent of the national government, whatever its scorecard says.

NotesMethod and data notes

Source. Controller of Budget, County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report for FY 2025/26, August 2026: executive summary, Table 2.1, Table 2.2, Section 4.7, Section 5.3, Annex I, and each county’s revenue table, revenue arrears table and OSR narrative in Chapter Three.

FIF in this article excludes Appropriations-in-Aid (AiA), which Table 2.1 combines with FIF. AiA from seven counties (Embu, Kirinyaga, Kisumu, Migori, Nairobi City, Narok and Uasin Gishu) totals KSh 649.27 m and is removed using Annex I. National FIF target: KSh 32.99 bn. FIF cash received: KSh 34.69 bn, 105.16 per cent of target, 44.09 per cent of all OSR cash (KSh 78.68 bn). The lift in Graph 1 is total OSR efficiency minus ordinary OSR efficiency, both on cash received, and so includes the small AiA amounts.

Cash received is the “actual receipts” column of each county revenue table, as in The Efficiency Illusion, Part 1 of this series. FIF booked but not received (KSh 4.98 bn) is the difference between Table 2.1 and those receipts in Garissa, Kisumu, Kitui, Marsabit, Mombasa, Murang’a, Nakuru, Narok and Tharaka-Nithi. Elgeyo-Marakwet: Table 2.1 and Annex I record FIF of KSh 403.11 m, which equals the county’s FIF of KSh 326.93 m plus its ordinary OSR of KSh 76.18 m; the county chapter confirms total OSR of KSh 403.11 m. Kisumu: the FIF target includes KSh 1.87 bn of SHIF receivables brought forward. Nyeri: FIF omitted by the Controller.

Unpaid claims. “Billed in 2025/26 and unpaid” is the FIF portion of the column “arrears earned in FY 2025/26” in county arrears tables (KSh 8.86 bn; see The Efficiency Illusion for reconciliation notes on Kajiado and Nakuru). Receivable balances are from Table 2.2, summed county by county; Tharaka-Nithi’s closing FIF balance (KSh 167.23 m) is taken from its county table. Kwale and Taita-Taveta report no usable Table 2.2 entries.

Composition categories follow each county’s stream labels: SHIF and SHA (including “SHIF/Cost sharing” and “Hospital Revenue-SHIF”); defunct NHIF; cash fees and other facility income (public health fees, hospital cash collections, medical service fees, user fees, other FIF sources, other insurers and donor receipts at facilities); and not itemised (a single FIF line, hospital revenue or medical services with no further detail).

Start of the series: Part 1The Efficiency Illusion: What Kenya’s County Revenue Scorecard Does Not Tell You
Policy Oracle Limited · Devolution Series, Part 3 · Analysis of public data from the Office of the Controller of Budget, Republic of Kenya. Figures verified against the source tables.