POLICY ORACLE
Devolution Series · Part 5 · The Final Report

Devolution Series · Part 5 of 5 · FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26

The Devolution Ledger: Six Years, KSh 2.64 Trillion and the Reforms FY 2026/27 Cannot Postpone

KSh 0bn
spent by Kenya's 47 county governments in six financial years

Nearly half went on wages and a quarter on development. KSh 511 billion of approved development money was never spent, and the stock of unpaid bills has risen 80 per cent since 2021. As counties enter the last full financial year before the August 2027 general election, Policy Oracle reviews where the money came from, where it went, what was lost, and what policy must now do.

Scroll
0spent by counties, FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26
0of it on compensation of employees
0of approved development budgets never spent
0in unpaid bills at 30 June 2026
0of own-revenue targets missed over six years
0years with the wage bill above the 35% ceiling

This is the final report in Policy Oracle's Devolution Series. Parts 1 to 4 examined a single year, FY 2025/26, through the lens of county revenue: the gap between headline and cash collections, the three counties that met their ordinary revenue targets, the rise of hospital revenue, and the anatomy of one county's failure in Siaya. Part 5 widens the frame to six years of Controller of Budget data and asks the question that matters for FY 2026/27: what has devolution done with its money, and what must change?

The short answer is that devolution has not failed for want of money. County budgets grew 29.2 per cent in nominal terms between FY 2020/21 and FY 2025/26, and the funds actually available to counties grew 36.7 per cent. What has failed is conversion: of budgets into cash, of cash into spending, and of spending into development. Each of those conversions leaks, and the leaks have grown.

01

The moneyMore money every year, and a widening gap between promise and delivery

Step 1 · The promiseApproved county budgets rose from KSh 501.74 billion in FY 2020/21 to KSh 648.23 billion in FY 2025/26. They fell only once, in FY 2022/23, the financial year of the 2022 general election.
Step 2 · The money that arrivedFunds actually available to counties, from the equitable share, grants, own revenue and balances carried forward, rose to KSh 596.78 billion. Every year, between KSh 49 billion and KSh 99 billion of approved spending had no money behind it. That shaded gap is the cost of revenue estimates that were never going to be met.
Step 3 · The money that was spentSpending grew more slowly than the money available, reaching KSh 496.58 billion. The money that arrived but was not spent by 30 June rose from KSh 38.60 billion in FY 2020/21 to KSh 100.20 billion in FY 2025/26, more than two and a half times as much.
Step 4 · The two gaps togetherIn FY 2025/26, KSh 151.65 billion, 23.4 per cent of approved county budgets, was either never funded or funded and not spent. The first gap is a budgeting failure. The second is an execution failure. Both have to close for devolution to deliver.

Figure 1

County budgets, funds available and spending, FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26

Approved budgetFunds availableSpendingUnfundedUnspent
KSh billion, nominal. Source: Controller of Budget annual County Governments Budget Implementation Review Reports; Policy Oracle analysis.
02

The flowsWhere FY 2025/26's KSh 596.78 billion came from and where it went

The equitable share remains the foundation of county finance. In FY 2025/26 it supplied KSh 415.00 billion, 69.5 per cent of all funds available. Own revenue of every kind (ordinary own-source revenue, Facility Improvement Financing, appropriations-in-aid and other revenue) supplied KSh 97.56 billion, 16.3 per cent. Additional allocations from the national government and development partners supplied KSh 50.75 billion, and balances carried forward KSh 33.48 billion.

On the other side of the ledger, compensation of employees took KSh 235.96 billion, 39.5 per cent of everything available. Operations and maintenance took KSh 133.92 billion and development KSh 126.69 billion. The remaining KSh 100.20 billion was not spent by the end of the year.

Figure 2

The county money flow, FY 2025/26

Each ribbon is proportional to the money it carries. Hover a ribbon or a block to isolate it.

KSh billion. Own revenue uses the Controller's conclusion chapter breakdown (ordinary KSh 55.69bn, FIF KSh 39.75bn, A-i-A KSh 0.65bn, other KSh 1.47bn). Source: Controller of Budget, County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report FY 2025/26, chapters 2 and 6; Policy Oracle analysis.

Over six years the pattern is stable and unflattering. Of the KSh 2.64 trillion counties spent, KSh 1.23 trillion (46.5 per cent) went on compensation, KSh 742.08 billion (28.1 per cent) on operations and maintenance and KSh 672.20 billion (25.4 per cent) on development. Wages have grown at 6.04 per cent a year; development spending at 1.77 per cent.

Figure 3

What counties spent their money on, FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26

Switch between shillings and shares. The amber line marks the 30 per cent minimum for development expenditure.

Compensation of employeesOperations and maintenanceDevelopment
Source: Controller of Budget annual reports, FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26; Policy Oracle analysis.

Figure 4

Six years of growth, indexed to FY 2020/21 = 100

Own revenue nearly tripled, driven by hospital revenue after the Facility Improvement Financing Act, 2023. Development barely moved.

Own-source revenueCompensationApproved budgetOperations and maintenanceDevelopment
Nominal values. Source: Controller of Budget annual reports; Policy Oracle analysis.
03

The development deficitKSh 511 billion approved for development and never spent

Section 107(2)(b) of the Public Finance Management Act requires counties to allocate at least 30 per cent of their budgets to development over the medium term, and Regulation 25(1)(g) of the PFM (County Governments) Regulations, 2015 requires actual development spending to conform. Counties have generally met the first test on paper: development made up 36.05 per cent of approved budgets in FY 2025/26. They have failed the second in practice. Development spending has not reached 30 per cent of total county expenditure in any of the six years; the closest was 29.16 per cent in FY 2020/21. In FY 2025/26 it was 25.51 per cent.

Over six years counties approved KSh 1.18 trillion for development and spent KSh 672.20 billion. The difference, KSh 511.34 billion, is 43.2 per cent of everything approved: roads not built, water systems not extended, health centres not equipped. Development absorption fell from 62.1 per cent in FY 2020/21 to 54.21 per cent in FY 2025/26, when 42 counties absorbed less than three-quarters of their development budgets.

Figure 5

Development budgets against development spending, by year

The outlined column is the approved development budget; the solid column is what was spent. Hover a year for the absorption rate.

Approved development budgetDevelopment spendingUnspent
KSh billion. Source: Controller of Budget annual reports; Policy Oracle analysis.
04

The wage billSix years above the ceiling

Regulation 25(1)(b) of the PFM (County Governments) Regulations, 2015 caps county spending on wages and benefits at 35 per cent of total revenue. Measured against funds available, county compensation has exceeded that ceiling in every one of the six years, peaking at 43.56 per cent in FY 2021/22 and easing to 39.54 per cent in FY 2025/26, the figure the Controller reports. At that ratio, counties spent KSh 27.09 billion more on compensation in FY 2025/26 than the ceiling allows.

The Controller records that the Wage Bill and Productivity Conference of April 2024 resolved to bring county wage bills within the 35 per cent threshold by 30 June 2028. FY 2026/27 is therefore the second-to-last year of that glide path, and it coincides with an election year, when pressure to hire is highest.

Figure 6

County compensation of employees as a share of funds available

The shaded band above the amber line is spending beyond the statutory ceiling. Hover for the shilling amount.

Compensation divided by total funds available. FY 2021/22, FY 2022/23 and FY 2025/26 ratios match the Controller's published figures; other years are Policy Oracle calculations from the same reports.
05

Own revenueCollections nearly tripled. Targets were still missed every year.

Own-source revenue rose from KSh 34.44 billion in FY 2020/21 to KSh 96.08 billion in FY 2025/26. The step change came after FY 2022/23, when the Facility Improvement Financing Act, 2023 allowed public hospitals to retain and report their revenue at source. In FY 2025/26, FIF and appropriations-in-aid made up KSh 40.40 billion, 42.0 per cent of own revenue. Ordinary own-source revenue, the taxes, rates, fees and charges counties levy directly, was KSh 55.68 billion.

Counties missed their own-revenue targets in all six years, by a cumulative KSh 116.02 billion. Performance improved from 64.2 per cent of target to 90.3 per cent, but as Part 1 showed, the FY 2025/26 headline counts revenue booked but not received. On a cash basis it was 73.91 per cent. As Part 4 showed in Siaya, an unmet target is not a neutral forecasting error: it is a hole in an approved budget.

Figure 7

Own-source revenue against target, FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26

Solid columns show collections; outlined columns show targets. From FY 2023/24, collections include hospital revenue retained under the FIF Act.

TargetCollectedFacility Improvement Financing Act, 2023
KSh billion. FY 2025/26 uses the Controller's Table 2.1 basis (KSh 96.08bn against KSh 106.45bn). Source: Controller of Budget annual reports.
06

LeakageIdle money, overdue bills and money already lost

Not every unspent shilling is wasted, and not every pending bill is a scandal. But the Controller's FY 2025/26 report documents a set of leakages that, taken together, show how much public value is lost between appropriation and service delivery. The largest is the stock of unpaid bills. It rose from KSh 96.0 billion in June 2021 to a peak of KSh 181.98 billion in June 2024, and stood at KSh 172.53 billion in June 2026, 80 per cent above its 2021 level.

Figure 8

County pending bills, June 2021 to June 2026, and how old they are

Left: the stock of unpaid bills at each year end. Right: the age of the June 2026 stock. Hover for detail.

Under 1 year1 to 2 years2 to 3 yearsOver 3 years
KSh billion. The FY 2024/25 report gives two year-end totals (KSh 176.80bn and KSh 183.06bn); Policy Oracle uses the lower figure. Ageing from the Controller's FY 2025/26 observations chapter. Sources: Controller of Budget annual reports.

Bills older than three years, KSh 71.64 billion, now make up 41.67 per cent of the stock; salaries and statutory deductions account for KSh 58.82 billion. Nairobi City alone owes KSh 86.90 billion, half the national total and 194.75 per cent of its own annual budget. The Controller warns that the stock "will reduce fiscal space" in FY 2026/27.

0available in FY 2025/26 but not spent by 30 June
0in revenue arrears owed to counties at 30 June 2026, more than a full year's own revenue
0already paid on 189 stalled projects worth KSh 10.51bn in 22 counties
0commercial bank accounts operated by counties, many without filed authorisation
0county fund regulations lapsed beyond their ten-year legal life (June 2025)
0of KSh 87.74bn in additional allocations received in FY 2025/26 (57.85%)
0on MCA sitting allowances in FY 2025/26, 88.90% of budget
0counties that filed FY 2025/26 reports by the 15 July 2026 deadline
07

The atlasForty-seven counties, five tests

National totals conceal wide variation. The atlas maps every county on five measures from FY 2025/26. Development absorption ranged from 84.52 per cent in Kilifi to 25.92 per cent in Kisumu. Pending bills ranged from almost nothing in Lamu to nearly twice the annual budget in Nairobi City. Select a lens, then select a county for its full profile.

Figure 9

The county atlas, FY 2025/26

Select a county on the map or in the lists below.

Sources: Controller of Budget FY 2025/26, Tables 2.4, 2.5 and 2.10; ordinary OSR from Part 2 of this series (cash basis). Nandi did not report pending bills.
08

The seriesWhat Parts 1 to 4 found

Read together, the four parts point to one diagnosis. County revenue targets are set to close budget gaps rather than to forecast collections. Hospital revenue now flatters own-revenue performance. Collections reported as revenue include money not yet received. And the shortfalls that follow fall on development, suppliers and primary care, not on payroll. The six-year data in this report show that the diagnosis is not peculiar to FY 2025/26. It is structural.

09

The year aheadFY 2026/27: more money, an election and a deadline

Counties enter FY 2026/27 with more money and less room. The Division of Revenue Act, 2026, assented to on 15 June 2026, allocates KSh 428 billion to counties as their equitable share, KSh 13 billion more than in FY 2025/26 and a nominal increase of 3.1 per cent. The figure was settled after mediation between the two Houses; the Commission on Revenue Allocation had recommended KSh 458 billion and the Council of Governors had asked for KSh 534 billion. Additional allocations of about KSh 75.5 billion are expected on top, bringing projected transfers to about KSh 503.5 billion.

Three pressures will shape the year. The first is the general election of August 2027: FY 2026/27 is the final full financial year of the current county administrations, the year in which unpaid bills are most easily passed to successors. The second is the wage-bill deadline of June 2028. The third is the debt overhang: the Parliamentary Budget Office's County Fiscal Policy Perspectives for FY 2027/28, released on 17 November 2026, proposes a three-year programme beginning in FY 2027/28 to clear the KSh 172.5 billion stock by 2030, prioritising small suppliers.

The simulator below shows how tightly these pressures bind. It starts from FY 2025/26 actuals and the FY 2026/27 equitable share. Adjust the assumptions to see what happens to the wage ratio, the development share and the stock of unpaid bills.

Figure 10

FY 2026/27 policy simulator: can counties meet the wage ceiling, the development floor and cut their bills at the same time?

An illustrative model, not a forecast. Revenue = KSh 428bn equitable share + additional allocations received + own revenue + KSh 33.48bn carried forward. Development = the share of money left after wages, operations and bill payments that counties actually spend on development.

Scenario
Baselines from Controller of Budget FY 2025/26: own revenue KSh 96.08bn; compensation KSh 235.96bn; operations and maintenance KSh 133.92bn; pending bills KSh 172.53bn; bills under one year old KSh 46.69bn; development spent 55.8% of funds left after wages and operations. Six-year growth rates: compensation 6.04% a year, operations and maintenance 4.80%.
10

The agendaTen reforms for the year before the election

Policy Oracle's recommendations follow the evidence of the series. Each names the office responsible, the legal anchor where one exists, and a measurable test that the Controller of Budget's next annual report can be used to check.

The verdictDevolution is under-executed, not underfunded

Six years of data do not support the claim that devolution has failed. Counties now raise nearly three times the own revenue they raised in FY 2020/21. They spend between 75 and 83 per cent of their budgets each year. Hospital revenue, retained at source, has given health facilities a financial life of their own. These are real gains.

But the gains sit on a weak frame. Budgets promise money that does not arrive. Money that arrives is not spent. Money that is spent goes disproportionately to wages, and the development that was the point of devolution grows at less than two per cent a year in nominal terms. Unpaid bills are 80 per cent higher, unspent cash is two and a half times larger and county finances are harder to read than they were six years ago.

The next phase of devolution will not be won by a larger equitable share. It will be won by credible budgets, honest revenue estimates and the discipline to pay what is owed before promising more.

FY 2026/27 is the test. It is the last full year before voters judge the current county administrations, and the last chance for this cohort of governors, county executives and assemblies to leave their successors a cleaner ledger than the one they inherited.

A note on the data. The Controller's FY 2025/26 report is internally inconsistent in places. Own revenue is given as KSh 96.08 billion (90.25 per cent of KSh 106.45 billion) in chapter 2 and KSh 97.55 billion (89.99 per cent of KSh 108.40 billion) in chapters 4 and 6. Salary arrears and statutory deductions in trade payables are KSh 100.24 billion in section 2.4.8 and KSh 58.82 billion in chapter 4. Commercial bank accounts at June 2025 are given as 5,092 and 5,476. No county met the reporting deadline. Fixing county finance begins with publishing county finance data that adds up, in machine-readable form.

NotesMethod and sources

  1. All values are nominal Kenya shillings. Six-year series come from the Controller of Budget's annual County Governments Budget Implementation Review Reports for FY 2020/21 to FY 2025/26 and are taken from each report's executive summary or financial analysis chapter. Where figures were restated in later reports, Policy Oracle uses the report for the year concerned.
  2. Funds available is the total of equitable share received, additional allocations, own revenue and cash balances brought forward, as reported by the Controller. Unfunded budget is approved budget less funds available; unspent funds are funds available less expenditure. These are Policy Oracle's derived measures.
  3. The wage ratio is compensation of employees divided by funds available. The Controller's published ratios for FY 2021/22 (43.6 per cent), FY 2022/23 (41.9 per cent) and FY 2025/26 (39.54 per cent) match this method.
  4. Own revenue before FY 2023/24 and after is not strictly comparable: the Facility Improvement Financing Act, 2023 changed how hospital revenue is retained and reported.
  5. The FY 2026/27 simulator is illustrative. It holds the balance carried forward at the FY 2025/26 level, applies growth rates to FY 2025/26 actuals, and assumes the share of residual funds spent on development is the only execution constraint. It is a tool for testing trade-offs, not a forecast.
  6. County atlas values are from the FY 2025/26 report. Ordinary OSR performance uses cash receipts as computed in Part 2. The Controller flags inconsistent payables data for several counties.

Sources

  • Controller of Budget, County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report FY 2025/26, August 2026.
  • Controller of Budget, County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report FY 2024/25, August 2025 (copy).
  • Controller of Budget, County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report FY 2023/24, August 2024 (copy).
  • Controller of Budget, County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report FY 2022/23, September 2023 (extract), with year-end figures as reported by The Star and People Daily.
  • Controller of Budget, Annual County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report FY 2021/22, September 2022 (copy).
  • Controller of Budget, County Governments Budget Implementation Review Report FY 2020/21, September 2021 (copy).
  • Parliament of Kenya, Division of Revenue Act, 2026 and County Allocation of Revenue Act, 2026 (parliament.go.ke; The Star).
  • Parliamentary Budget Office, County Fiscal Policy Perspectives FY 2027/28, November 2026 (as reported by Kenyans.co.ke).
  • Commission on Revenue Allocation and Council of Governors positions on the FY 2026/27 equitable share (The Standard).
Return to the start of the series: Part 1The Efficiency Illusion